NEVER GIVE UP: The Incredible Story of PlayDoh's Miraculous Homecoming
Lost in the Wilderness for 12 Days, One Little Horse Proved That Miracles Really Do Happen
A Special Story Revisited by Stolen Horse International–NetPosse
What would you do if your beloved horse suddenly disappeared into thousands of acres of unfamiliar wilderness? How long would you search? How long would you hold on to hope?
For one Pennsylvania horse owner in 2016, those questions became a terrifying reality. What followed was a remarkable story of heartbreak, determination, strangers becoming friends, and a reunion that reminds us why we must never underestimate the power of hope.
At Stolen Horse International–NetPosse, we are sharing this incredible story again for a very important reason.
Somewhere today, a horse owner is searching. Someone is exhausted, discouraged, and wondering whether their missing horse will ever come home. Someone helping with a search may be questioning whether their efforts are making a difference.
This story is for them.
Because sometimes, when the odds seem impossible, something extraordinary happens.
And sometimes, miracles have four legs.
A Beautiful Day Turns Into a Nightmare
On May 27, 2016, Susan Crawford's beloved Paso Fino horse, PlayDoh, disappeared after becoming frightened following a fall during a trail ride near Maryland's Patapsco Valley State Park.
In an instant, a day that should have been filled with wonderful memories became every horse owner's nightmare.
PlayDoh bolted into the wilderness, still wearing his saddle, bridle, reins, and other riding equipment.
Imagine the fear
A horse alone in unfamiliar territory is frightening enough. But a horse running loose through thick woods with tack still attached faces additional dangers. Reins can become tangled. Saddles can catch on branches. Injuries can occur, and finding an animal in miles of wooded terrain can seem almost impossible.
Susan knew her horse was out there somewhere. She just didn't know where. And she wasn't about to give up.
An Army of Hope Begins to Form
Susan immediately began searching and contacted Stolen Horse International (NetPosse.com) for help.
What happened next demonstrated something we have witnessed repeatedly throughout our years of helping missing horse owners:
One missing horse can bring an entire community together. Friends, family members, horseback riders, hikers, volunteers, and law enforcement joined the effort. Some searched on horseback. Others walked the trails, carefully looking for clues.
Flyers were distributed throughout the area. Social media posts spread the word, and news outlets covered the disappearance. People suggested drones, helicopters, tracking dogs, and organized searches.
Stolen Horse International sent NetPosse email alerts nationwide, helping carry PlayDoh's story far beyond the Maryland woods.
Day after day, people continued looking. But PlayDoh remained missing. One day became two. Two became five. Then a week passed.
With every passing day, the uncertainty grew. Was PlayDoh injured? Was he trapped somewhere? Was he still alive?
Nobody knew. Yet the search continued.
One Volunteer Understood the Heartbreak All Too Well
Among those helping was a man named Jeff Dwyer.
Jeff wasn't simply another volunteer. He was a missing horse victim himself, still searching for his own horses. He understood the anguish of not knowing where a beloved animal was or what had happened to it.
Despite carrying that heartbreak, Jeff devoted countless hours to helping Susan find PlayDoh. He searched on horseback, worked tirelessly in the area, and kept Stolen Horse International informed as the days passed.
Think about that for a moment. Here was someone living through his own painful search, yet he refused to turn away from another horse owner who desperately needed help.
Jeff's dedication reminds us that sometimes the people who understand our pain most deeply are the very ones who step forward to help us through it.
His involvement became an important part of PlayDoh's journey home.
Twelve Days Missing. Then Came the Phone Call.
June 8, 2016.
After 12 long days of searching, worrying, hoping, and praying, something incredible happened.
Three hikers—David Sugar, Vlad Konstantinov, and Emily Perryman—came across a horse in the woods.
It was PlayDoh!
Remarkably, the hikers had seen a missing horse flyer at the Woodstock Inn. They recognized the horse and helped bring an end to nearly two weeks of uncertainty.
PlayDoh had been found approximately three miles from where he originally disappeared. And incredibly, he was still wearing his tack, including his reins.
After nearly two weeks in the wilderness, he was alive. The little horse so many people had refused to stop searching for had finally been found.
Imagine Susan receiving that news. After all the sleepless nights, the fear, the unanswered questions, and the desperate searching, someone had finally found her horse.
The moment she had been praying for was real. PlayDoh was coming back.
Battered, Bruised, but Alive
PlayDoh's ordeal had taken a toll. He was covered in cuts, scrapes, and painful rubs from his tack. One wound was approximately five inches long and an inch and a half deep.
He was stiff, tired, and certainly looked as though he had endured an adventure no horse should ever experience.
But there was encouraging news. He was not dehydrated, and his injuries were not considered life-threatening. A veterinarian examined him and provided guidance for his recovery.
And perhaps one of the most touching details of the entire story came from Jeff Dwyer. According to Jeff, PlayDoh was thrilled to see Susan again. He even seemed happy to see the horse trailer and return to civilization! After surviving nearly two weeks alone in the woods, PlayDoh was finally surrounded by familiar faces and caring hands.
He was safe.
A Homecoming Worth Celebrating
Once PlayDoh was cleared to travel, Susan and Jeff helped transport him to Ebb Tide Stables, where he could continue receiving care. On June 10, 2016, PlayDoh finally made the journey back to his home in Pennsylvania.
But this wasn't just an ordinary homecoming. Family members and friends gathered to celebrate the return of the little horse who had captured so many hearts.
There was a welcome-home party. Smiles, laughter, relief, and undoubtedly a few happy tears filled the room. And, of course, there were plenty of carrots for the guest of honor!
PlayDoh was home. After everything he had endured, he was back where he belonged, surrounded by the people who loved him.
For Susan, the volunteers, and everyone who had followed his disappearance, it was a moment they would never forget.
PlayDoh Today: Twenty and Going Strong
Ten years after that long walk home, PlayDoh is 20 years old — and going strong.
He and Susan still camp out and go on trail rides. He has tried cow sorting, mounted shooting, and barrel racing. He has ridden on the beach, scrambled up mountains, and crossed many rivers. Several years ago, they joined the Michigan Trail Riders on their shore-to-shore ride — ten days, 250 miles. He still has a lot of energy.
For all his quirks, he is an excellent trail horse. He will go anywhere you ask him to go — and when other horses are nervous about an obstacle, Susan lets PlayDoh go first.
He may be mellowing with age, but on a nice day, when he would rather stay out in the pasture, he can still be difficult to catch. And for many years, if PlayDoh got loose for any reason, people who knew his story would panic that he would run off again. Thankfully, he never has.
The first time Susan and PlayDoh went back to Patapsco together, they were both nervous. Susan didn't realize how anxious it would make her to go back — and PlayDoh seemed anxious, too.
He was happy to be home, though, and he got so much TLC from everyone around the barn.
What Susan Wants Other Owners to Know
Susan has followed the stories of other lost horses since PlayDoh came home, and one thing keeps standing out to her: they are found fairly close to where they were lost. PlayDoh himself was found only about three miles from where he ran off.
"I would search every square inch within a small circle of where their horse went missing," she says. "I think it is easy to assume they went for miles, but it doesn't seem to be the case."
And for anyone going through it now, her advice is simple: stay around positive people who will tell you all the reasons to keep your hopes up. A Facebook page was started for PlayDoh, and the administrator kindly kept the negative comments off it — people said some cruel things, but Susan was protected from most of them. What she remembers is all the great people who came out and looked.
Stay busy, too. Susan spent her days contacting everyone she could think of who might help — from drone clubs to the police, even asking about an amber alert.
PlayDoh's story didn't end the day he came home. Ten years later, he is still out on the trail — still leading the way over the scary spots, still full of energy, still home.
The Real Miracle Was Bigger Than One Horse
Although PlayDoh's safe return was extraordinary, something else about this story deserves to be remembered.
People came together. Strangers gave their time. Volunteers searched despite having no personal connection to the horse. People shared flyers, walked trails, rode horses, contacted others, and continued spreading the word.
Three hikers remembered a flyer and recognized a missing horse. And a man who was still searching for his own missing horses devoted himself to helping someone else find hers.
No single person made this reunion happen alone. It took an entire network of caring people.
After PlayDoh's return, Susan thanked everyone who participated in the search.
She also reflected on how remarkable it was to see so many different people come together for one little Paso Fino horse. At a time when the news often seemed filled with negativity, the experience reminded her that caring communities still exist.
That lesson remains just as powerful today.
Why Stolen Horse International Is Sharing This Story Again
Nearly a decade has passed since PlayDoh disappeared into those Maryland woods. Yet his story carries a message that will never grow old.
Never give up simply because the search has become difficult.
At Stolen Horse International–NetPosse, we know that not every missing horse case has a quick resolution. Some horses are found within hours. Others remain missing for weeks, months, or even years.
We also know how emotionally devastating these cases can be. There are days when leads disappear, searches come up empty, and hope feels impossibly far away.
Families grow exhausted. Volunteers become discouraged. The world moves on, even though the owner cannot.
But PlayDoh's story reminds us that a search can change in an instant. A flyer posted in the right place. A stranger who remembers seeing a photograph. A volunteer who decides to search one more trail. A person who shares an alert that eventually reaches someone with information.
Sometimes, one small action becomes the missing piece that brings a horse home. That is why Stolen Horse International encourages owners to keep their missing-horse information circulating and to pursue credible leads whenever possible.
It is also why we ask the public not to forget the horses that are still missing. Your involvement matters. Even when you cannot see the results, your efforts may be helping more than you realize.
To Every Horse Owner Still Searching
If your horse is missing today, we want you to know something. You have not been forgotten.
We understand that uncertainty can feel unbearable.
We understand the heartbreak of looking toward an empty pasture, an empty stall, or a familiar place where your horse should be standing. We understand how hard it is to keep hoping when answers feel so far away.
We cannot promise that every search will end like PlayDoh's. But we can remind you that remarkable reunions do happen.
Horses have been recovered after extraordinary circumstances and against seemingly impossible odds.
And sometimes the person who helps bring a horse home is someone who has never even met the owner.
As long as there is a possibility of finding answers, your horse's story deserves to be remembered.
To the Volunteers, Friends, and Strangers Who Help
This message is also for you.
For the person who shares a missing horse alert.
For the volunteer who spends another weekend searching.
For the friend who makes phone calls, posts flyers, or checks a possible sighting.
For the stranger who stops to look more closely at a horse because something seems familiar.
And for those who continue supporting a missing horse owner long after the initial excitement of the search has faded.
Please don't underestimate what your efforts mean. You may never know which flyer, conversation, photograph, or shared post will make the difference.
But the hikers who found PlayDoh had seen his flyer. That one detail should remind all of us why spreading the word matters.
Never Underestimate the Power of One
PlayDoh's story is more than a happy ending from 2016.
It is a reminder of what can happen when determination meets compassion, when strangers become a team, and when people refuse to let a missing horse be forgotten.
One owner refused to stop searching.
One community came together.
One volunteer gave his time despite his own heartbreak.
Three hikers recognized a horse from a flyer.
And one very special little Paso Fino finally made it home.
Today, we share PlayDoh's story again in honor of every missing horse, every heartbroken owner, and every person who continues to help.
Because you never know when the next phone call will bring the news someone has been waiting desperately to hear.
"We found your horse."
Four simple words. A lifetime of gratitude. And a reminder that sometimes, miracles really do happen.
"Never give up hope. Never stop caring. Never underestimate the power of one." — Debi Metcalfe, Founder of Stolen Horse International–NetPosse
HELP US BRING MORE HORSES HOME
Stolen Horse International–NetPosse is a nonprofit organization dedicated to helping reunite missing, stolen, and lost horses with their rightful owners.
If your horse is missing, file a report at www.netposse.com so we can document your case and spread awareness through our NetPosse network.
If you see a missing horse alert, please share it. If you recognize a horse, report the information.
If you know someone still searching, remind them they are not alone. Because the next miracle could begin with YOU.
Originally reported in June 2016. Republished by Stolen Horse International–NetPosse to honor PlayDoh's remarkable recovery and encourage those still searching for missing horses.
Special recognition goes to Susan Crawford, Jeff Dwyer, David Sugar, Vlad Konstantinov, Emily Perryman, and the many volunteers, friends, and supporters who helped bring PlayDoh home.
Stolen Horse International provides news and other resources for free on this website. As a charitable organization we survive on the kindness of people like you. Please consider donating to help fund the organization or purchasing a NetPosse ID for your horse, dog or cat to help protect your beloved animals!
Debi Metcalfe
Founder | debi@netposse.com
Ten years after that long walk home, PlayDoh is 20 years old â€" and going strong. He and Susan still camp out and go on trail rides. He has tried cow sorting, mounted shooting, and barrel racing. He has ridden on the beach, scrambled up mountains, and crossed many rivers. Several years ago, they joined the Michigan Trail Riders on their shore-to-shore ride â€" ten days, 250 miles. He still has a lot of energy.
PlayDoh's story didn't end the day he came home. Ten years later, he is still out on the trail â€" still leading the way over the scary spots, still full of energy, still home.
See PlayDoh's welcome home video on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8MWpouBWWqU
CBS News Story: After Nearly 2 Weeks, Missing Horse 'Playdoh' Found Safe https://www.cbsnews.com/baltimore/news/after-nearly-2-weeks-missing-horse-playdoh-found-safe/
Comments